South African coal price surge, while others languish, is troubling: Russell Price,  International 2019-12-05 17:16:27

Coal prices around the world are gently sliding as demand from top importers such as China, India and even Europe remains subdued amid a so far mild northern winter. However, there is one exception.

South African coal export prices at Richards Bay have surged in recent months, defying market fundamentals and seemingly without logical explanation.

It's clear that the movements for South African coal are wildly out of step with what's going on in the other major regions, according to some price benchmarks.

There is no obvious fundamental reason why this should be the case.

There is neither supply shock for exports from Richards Bay, or a sudden surge in demand for either South African coal specifically, or coal from other exporters of a similar quality.

Richards Bay exports were 6.08 million tonnes in November, according to vessel-tracking and port data compiled by Refinitiv, down slightly from 6.89 million tonnes in October.

However, it's worth noting that October was the best month since December last year and November's exports were the fourth-highest for any month this year.

The bulk of South Africa's coal exports head to Asia, with India ranking as the biggest buyer.

India's imports of coal from all countries did tick up in November to 16.36 million tonnes from 14.78 million tonnes in October.

But the increase wasn't driven by additional demand for South African coal, with India's imports from Richards Bay coming in at 2.99 million tonnes in November, up slightly from 2.69 million in October.

Trading play

If fundamentals can be ruled out as behind the increase in South African coal prices, the explanation most likely lies in trading tactics being used by market participants.

The motivation is likely to be to create arbitrage opportunities between physical and paper markets, or perhaps also to influence prices linked to longer-term contract negotiations.

While this may lead to winning some short-term profits, it risks damaging the longer-term integrity of the market.

There is little chance that buyers of South African coal across South Asia will accept paying a substantially higher price than what they could pay for similar quality Australian coal.

If the Richards Bay price continues to deviate from other prices, buyers will be reluctant to purchase South African cargoes, or demand a discount mechanism, or a switch to alternative pricing.

If an index price loses credibility or trustworthiness, it ceases to be of much use to the industry.

This is by no means a criticism of the methodology or integrity of compiling the indexes, which have robust procedures and checks in place.

If prices being offered and traded are genuine, there is little the price reporting agencies can do, especially if some players withdraw to the sidelines out of fear of taking losses, or a reduction in the liquidity in the market.

Overall, apart from possible short-term profits, there seems to be nothing to be gained by having one global coal price benchmark out of whack with the others.

It serves only to make coal an unattractive financial market, something an industry already under siege for its role in climate change would be best advised to avoid.

(Writing by Wenxin Wu  Editing by Alex Guo)
For any questions, please contact us by or +86-351-7219322.

Share this article
Connect with us

Editors Recommendations

1 China's daily crude steel output falls 2.68% in early Feb amid virus 2020-02-17

Daily crude steel output at China's key steel mills fell by 2.68% from ten days ago to 1.94 million tonnes in early February, according to data from the China Iron and Steel Association (CISA).

2 China's import thermal coal outlook clouded by recovering supply 2020-02-17

China's import thermal coal market outlook was clouded by quickened resumption of domestic coal production, which could dent buying demand for overseas coal while vessels from China face 14-day quaran

3 Coal mines speeding up to reopen, virus impacts on supply abates, NEA 2020-02-17

A quick comeback of coal mines has been seen last week from suspension amid the virus outbreak, according to sources with the National Energy Administration. Impacts by restrictions against the virus

4 Chinese thermal coal traders concerned about price drops on supply recovery 2020-02-17

Chinese thermal coal traders were concerned that prices of the fossil fuel may lose ground at northern transfer ports in the near term, with more coal mines restarting operation in key production area

5 China Coal Daily Track (Feb 17) 2020-02-17

Thermal coal Production area While many mines have restarted operations in Ordos, Inner Mongolia, most of them were still unable to reach normal production because returning workers are still i

6 Ordos brings 75 coal mines back into operation 2020-02-17

Production had been restarted at 75 coal mines in Ordos city, one leading coal hub in northern China's Inner Mongolia, as of February 13, with yearly capacity totaling 380 million tonnes, said the loc

7 Guangdong carbon market closes higher 2020-02-17

Carbon emissions allowances closed at 29.23 yuan/t ($4.19/t) on February 14, 2.53% up from a day earlier, at the China Emissions Exchange (Guangzhou), the largest local carbon market in China.

8 China iron ore futures hit bottom 2020-02-14

China's iron ore futures have hit the bottom and bearish sentiment arising from coronavirus outbreak seemed fading away, along with production resumption at downstream plants and construction sector.

9 China Coal Daily Track (Feb 14) 2020-02-14

Thermal coal Production area Yulin saw coal mines running at low operating rates, and a few large local miners that were operating mainly secured supply to their own firms. Coal supply remai

10 MEC halts coal exports to China after border shut 2020-02-14

Mongolia Energy Corporation (MEC) said it had to suspend coal exports to China until early next month, as the government had decided to close all border crossings with China to prevent the novel coron

Most Read Articles

1 Indonesian thermal coal solid on robust Chinese demand 2020-02-11

Indonesian thermal coal prices maintained an upward pace in the Chinese seaborne import market, as Chinese utilities released firm demand amid domestic supply woe caused by the ongoing coronavirus out

2 China's transport curbs add to thermal coal supply woes at N ports 2020-02-11

Transport curbs that were imposed by some provinces to avert virus spread are adding to thermal coal supply woes at northern China ports, raising upbeat prospects for further price rises in the follow

3 Chinese coal traders hunt for short-term buys amid virus disruption 2020-02-12

Chinese coal traders and small coal-fired utilities are scrambling to lock in supplies of fuel from miners, worried about the prospects of market tightness as downstream users return to work after an

4 China's spot thermal coal rallies to 4-mth high on undersupply 2020-02-13

Chinese spot thermal coal rallied to a four-month high on the back of long-standing undersupply at northern transfer ports, and the winning streak is likely to be sustained in the short term.

5 China coking coal supply sinks amid mines' slow resumption 2020-02-11

Coking coal supply kept sinking in China's main production areas on February 10, due mainly to slow production resumption at many mines alongside nationwide efforts to ward off novel coronavirus.

6 CHN Energy adjusts up Feb term contract coal prices, sources 2020-02-11

China's top coal producer CHN Energy, usually called Shenhua by Chinese coal industry insiders, increased its monthly contract thermal coal prices for February shipments, sources said. Th

7 Over half of China's coal mines resume production, top planner 2020-02-12

Production had been resumed at 57.8% of the coal mines in China as of February 10, according to a news briefing held by the country's top economic planner on February 11. Further recovery

8 Indonesia 2019 coal exports hit multi-yr high 2020-02-13

Indonesia exported 456 million tonnes of coal in 2019, hitting a new high at least since 2015, official data showed. The 2019 exports were up 6.43% compared with a year ago, according to

9 QHD port coal stocks slump to three-yr-plus trough on reduced supply 2020-02-12

Qinhuangdao port, a leading coal transfer hub in North China, saw coal stockpiles plummet to a three-year-plus low in early February amid China's coronavirus-interrupted coal supply. Inve

10 Mongolia shuts freight through border crossings on coronavirus fears 2020-02-11

Mongolia on February 9 announced to temporarily shut down road freight via border crossings with China on fears of the novel coronavirus epidemic, Mongolian media reported. The movement c

Scan to download mobile APP