Impact of Chinese overcapacity on global trade is exaggerated, study finds

reuters.com Viewpoint,  Production & Sales 2018-05-07 08:51:00

The concept of global excess capacity, commonly used to support the creation of trade defences against China, is imprecise and unsound as a justification for US protectionism, a study by a Swiss-based trade watchdog said.


Global Trade Alert, an initiative coordinated by Simon Evenett, professor of international trade at St Gallen University in Switzerland, sought to quantify excess capacity, especially in steel, and the damage to global trade.


Its report, by Evenett and Johannes Fritz, a research fellow at St Gallen, found that there was no compelling case for governments to get upset about global excess capacity in manufacturing.


"On examination, it turns out that the phrase excess capacity is slippery -- rhetorically useful, but hard to pin down, even harder to operationalise, and at the same time woefully misleading."


The United States, the European Union and Japan have accused China of trading unfairly by subsidising bloated steel and aluminium sectors and flooding the world with cheap exports.


US President Donald Trump has used China's mammoth steel and aluminium sectors as justification for imposing tariffs on global supplies, causing an outcry from many countries.


Global Trade Alert has catalogued global trade policies since 2009 to gauge trends in protectionism, following a pledge by the G20 group of countries in November 2008 not to resort to trade protectionism as a response to the financial crisis.


There was no question that the steel sector was plagued by trade distortions, the study said, but G20 governments had grossly under-reported their own use of trade-distorting policies.


"Even before the recent steel tariffs were imposed by the US, the cumulative effect of the 144 American actions to limit steel imports still in effect today covered 96.8% of US steel imports," the report said.


Targeting excess steel capacity was not sensible, because measuring it was very difficult, and estimates of China's steel production capacity varied enormously, it said.


Drawing on Chinese and US sources, the study said other sectors thought to have overcapacity included glass, shipbuilding, base metals, paper, chemicals, batteries and footwear.


But for most of those, Chinese overcapacity had little impact on global trade, the study said. China's exports of those products accounted for only a small proportion of its total exports and less than 2% of G20 countries' manufacturing imports, it found.


Since 2005, no more than 21% of world trade was in sectors where China was suspected of having overcapacity, and that number had fallen from 2011 to reach 18% in 2016.


(Writing by Jessie Jia  Editing by Harry Huo)
For any questions, please contact us by inqury@fwenergy.com or +86-351-7219322.

Share this article
Connect with us

Editors Recommendations

1 Weekly global coal market news summary (May 21 – May 25) 2018-05-25

Mongolia plans to launch $16 billion investment programme Mongolia is preparing to invite proposals for public-private partnerships that would make a combined 38.3 trillion tugrik ($15.95 bil

2 China Coal initiatively reduces price in response to NDRC policy 2018-05-25

China National Coal Group, the country's second largest coal miner, reportedly pared supply prices initiatively, in response to measures issued by the National Development and Reform Commission (ND

3 Chinese thermal coal market tilts down as govt policy measures kick in 2018-05-25

China's domestic thermal coal prices are set to drop from recent highs, as a slew of government policy measures kick in to cool down the red-hot market. The National Development an

4 Policy regulation aggravates sentiment in China thermal coal market 2018-05-25

Chinese authorities' countermeasures to stabilize thermal coal prices have aggravated wait-and-see sentiment in the domestic spot market. Preemptive traders started to conclude deals at a lower price,

5 China hydropower picking up in May, coal burns will go down gradually 2018-05-25

China's hydropower generation totaled 68.08 TWh over May 1-23, increasing 5.25% on the year, up 10.5 percentage points from the negative growth in April, data showed. Daily hydro

6 Chinese coke makers, traders concerned about downward risk after five hikes 2018-05-25

China's coke producers are concerned about the downward risk after the fifth price increase of 100 yuan/t starting May 23, sources said. Prices of the steel making material has gon

7 China's coke price up 5.2pct in mid-May, NBS 2018-05-25

Prices for China's Grade II met coke averaged 1,753.5 yuan/t in middle of May (May 11-20), rising 5.2% or 86.7 yuan/t from ten days ago, according to the sampling survey by the National Bureau of Stat

8 China urges EU to act 'prudent' on steel trade 2018-05-25

The European Union's frequent trade remedy investigations into China's steel products have seriously interfered with steel trade between the two economies, the Ministry of Commerce said on May 24, urg

9 China Apr thermal coal imports down 28.12% on mth 2018-05-24

China imported 9 million tonnes of thermal coal (bituminous and sub-bituminous) in April, tumbling 3.52 million tonnes or 28.12% from the preceding month and 0.78 million tonnes or 7.98% year on yea

10 China Coal Daily Track (May 24) 2018-05-24

Thermal coal Domestic market Price increments of slack thermal coal were maintained at 5-10 yuan/t recently at main production areas. Purchase sentiment of traders faded a little aft

Most Read Articles

1 N Korea intends to export coal to China after a diplomatic breakthrough with US 2018-05-16

Some North Korean traders were offering low-price coal to Chinese traders and have stored up a number of cargoes at North Korean ports, expecting to deliver them over the border when a diplomatic brea

2 China thermal coal market faces downward risks in short run 2018-05-16

Despite unexpected price rallies amid current slack season, China's thermal coal market at Bohai-rim ports is still facing downward risks in the short term, given little improvement of demand from uti

3 China Apr raw coal output up 4.1pct YoY, NBS 2018-05-15

China produced 293.3 million tonnes of raw coal in April, an increase of 4.1% year on year, showed data from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) on May 15. Over January-April, raw coa

4 Intensified environmental crackdown may cause new capacity cuts in China coke industry 2018-05-14

A new round of capacity cutback may stage in China's coke-making industry, as increasingly stringent environmental checks force producers to limit output. The move was led by Xuzhou

5 China's May coal imports may stay stable from Apr 2018-05-15

China's coal imports in May are expected to stay stable from the level recorded in April this year, as relevant authorities seemed to be less strict in banning import coal following continuous price r

6 As temperatures soar, China coal traders bet on shortages 2018-05-17

China's thermal coal futures rose to a six-week high on May 16 as traders bet on a supply crunch as lower hydro power output and forecasts of a summer heat wave spurred expectations of rising demand f

7 Notice on website upgrading 2018-05-17

Sxcoal.com will be undergoing upgrades on Saturday May 19, 2018, to bring you enhanced stability and improved experience. From 9:00-15:00 Beijing Time (GMT+8), you may experience intermitt

8 India's thermal coal imports rise over 15% in Q1 2018-05-14

India's thermal coal imports rose by more than 15% in the first three months of 2018, with Indonesia accounting for about three-fifths of total supplies, according to vessel arrival data from Dubai-ba

9 China's top 3 provinces contribute 67.5% of raw coal output in Jan-Apr 2018-05-17

Northern China's Inner Mongolia, Shanxi and Shaanxi produced 67.5% of the country's total raw coal in the first four months, showed data from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS). On M

10 China spot thermal coal market further ascends; worries linger on 2018-05-17

China's thermal coal market continued ascending at Bohai-rim ports following latest quick pick-ups, with offer prices jumping even higher on a lack of supply. Yet participants' worries over downside r