Impact of Chinese overcapacity on global trade is exaggerated, study finds

reuters.com Viewpoint,  Production & Sales 2018-05-07 08:51:00

The concept of global excess capacity, commonly used to support the creation of trade defences against China, is imprecise and unsound as a justification for US protectionism, a study by a Swiss-based trade watchdog said.


Global Trade Alert, an initiative coordinated by Simon Evenett, professor of international trade at St Gallen University in Switzerland, sought to quantify excess capacity, especially in steel, and the damage to global trade.


Its report, by Evenett and Johannes Fritz, a research fellow at St Gallen, found that there was no compelling case for governments to get upset about global excess capacity in manufacturing.


"On examination, it turns out that the phrase excess capacity is slippery -- rhetorically useful, but hard to pin down, even harder to operationalise, and at the same time woefully misleading."


The United States, the European Union and Japan have accused China of trading unfairly by subsidising bloated steel and aluminium sectors and flooding the world with cheap exports.


US President Donald Trump has used China's mammoth steel and aluminium sectors as justification for imposing tariffs on global supplies, causing an outcry from many countries.


Global Trade Alert has catalogued global trade policies since 2009 to gauge trends in protectionism, following a pledge by the G20 group of countries in November 2008 not to resort to trade protectionism as a response to the financial crisis.


There was no question that the steel sector was plagued by trade distortions, the study said, but G20 governments had grossly under-reported their own use of trade-distorting policies.


"Even before the recent steel tariffs were imposed by the US, the cumulative effect of the 144 American actions to limit steel imports still in effect today covered 96.8% of US steel imports," the report said.


Targeting excess steel capacity was not sensible, because measuring it was very difficult, and estimates of China's steel production capacity varied enormously, it said.


Drawing on Chinese and US sources, the study said other sectors thought to have overcapacity included glass, shipbuilding, base metals, paper, chemicals, batteries and footwear.


But for most of those, Chinese overcapacity had little impact on global trade, the study said. China's exports of those products accounted for only a small proportion of its total exports and less than 2% of G20 countries' manufacturing imports, it found.


Since 2005, no more than 21% of world trade was in sectors where China was suspected of having overcapacity, and that number had fallen from 2011 to reach 18% in 2016.


(Writing by Jessie Jia  Editing by Harry Huo)
For any questions, please contact us by inqury@fwenergy.com or +86-351-7219322.

Share this article
Connect with us

Editors Recommendations

1 Inner Mongolia to launch safety inspection after coal accident, source 2018-09-26

Northern China's coal production base Inner Mongolia has decided to conduct safety inspection on coal mines, source reported, after one coal mine accident happened in the region. The move

2 China coking coal market still resilient; coke prices down 2018-09-26

China's coking coal market remained buoyant on the whole after the Mid-autumn Festival, though further upward momentum may be dented by price cuts in metallurgical coke. On September 25,

3 Coal prices hold steady in production areas after Mid-autumn Festival 2018-09-26

Thermal coal prices remained almost unchanged in China's northern major production regions at the first day after the 3-day Mid-autumn Festival. On September 25, Fenwei assessed price of

4 China Coal Daily Track (Sep 26) 2018-09-26

Thermal coal Domestic market Production area Affected by weakening demand of coking and preparation plants in Shanxi, fewer trucks came over and stocks started building up at mine

5 China thermal coal traders in'wait-and-see' first day after holiday 2018-09-26

Chinese thermal coal market was in a "wait-and-see" mode after the 3-day holiday for Mid-autumn Festival. Offer prices stood still after a small increase during the holiday, while trades were seen as

6 China's import curbs continue crimping thermal coal buying 2018-09-26

Chinese utilities remained cautious about taking thermal coal from overseas suppliers as the government continues to curb import of the fossil fuel, with no material relaxation on import quota.

7 Thailand Aug thermal coal imports up 5% on yr 2018-09-26

Thailand imported 2.45 million tonnes of thermal coal in August, edging up 4.87% from a year ago, the latest customs data showed. Specifically, 888,900 tonnes was bituminous coal, down 33

8 Weekly China met. coke market analysis and forecast 2018-09-26

China's metallurgical coke market last week experienced the second price drop this month. Considering their profit margins remained high and steelmakers were deliberately controlling coke purchase,

9 Weekly China thermal coal market analysis and forecast 2018-09-26

Spot prices of thermal coal started to rebound at northern China ports late last week following days of decline, primarily due to shipment restriction at the top transfer hub of Qinhuangdao.

10 China thermal coal prices supported by multiple factors 2018-09-25

Prices of thermal coal – one key raw material to generate power – moved up at Bohai-rim ports in northern China, driven by a combination of factors. Supply of some premium thermal coals h

Most Read Articles

1 QHD coal stocks rise amid restrictions on outbound shipment 2018-09-18

Coal stocks at China's leading transfer port of Qinhuangdao edged higher, as outbound shipment has been limited by local government authorities for environmental purpose, traders said. Da

2 China thermal coal market softens; QHD coal stock exceeds 7 mln T 2018-09-19

China's thermal coal market ran even weaker after peak seasons, amid poor consumption of downstream users, especially for six major coastal utilities. On September 17, Fenwei CCI index fo

3 China's coal import quotas increase not officially confirmed, traders 2018-09-17

The Chinese government still hasn't released any documents on possible increase of import coal quotas for southern and eastern ports as of late last week, traders said. Traders have alway

4 Tangshan to impose differentiated production curbs on steel mills in winter heating season 2018-09-20

Tangshan, China's largest steel hub based in Hebei province, will impose differentiated production restrictions on steel mills from October 1 to the end of March next year, the city government announc

5 Indonesian coal prices advances after N China's port restricted shipment 2018-09-19

Indonesian miners raised their thermal coal offer prices after China's largest coal-dedicated port limited coal shipment, sources said. One Singapore-based trader reported Indonesian pric

6 Glencore returns to Japan coal talks scuppered by high prices 2018-09-17

Mining giant Glencore Plc and Japanese utilities have resumed thermal coal supply negotiations, restarting talks that fell apart earlier this year as prices hovered near a six-year high.

7 Coal exports in Indonesia hobbled with miners facing constraints 2018-09-20

Coal exports from Indonesia will be restrained this year, which could frustrate a plan by the government to ease a burgeoning trade deficit while keeping prices elevated, according to an industry grou

8 China may not lift restriction on import coal in short run, traders 2018-09-20

China may not relax its import coal restriction in the near future, traders said, regarding recent market talks that China will add import quotas to southern and eastern ports. Market tal

9 China Aug coal output rises despite environmental and safety checks 2018-09-19

China's raw coal output increased in August compared to the year-ago and month-ago levels, in spite of environmental and safety checks that impacted production in some production areas. T

10 Germany's RWE says too early to exit coal in 2035 2018-09-17

German utility RWE, its works council and trade unions say they oppose plans to end coal-fired power generation in Germany around 2035, raising questions over a possible compromise between a governmen