Impact of Chinese overcapacity on global trade is exaggerated, study finds

reuters.com Viewpoint,  Production & Sales 2018-05-07 08:51:00

The concept of global excess capacity, commonly used to support the creation of trade defences against China, is imprecise and unsound as a justification for US protectionism, a study by a Swiss-based trade watchdog said.


Global Trade Alert, an initiative coordinated by Simon Evenett, professor of international trade at St Gallen University in Switzerland, sought to quantify excess capacity, especially in steel, and the damage to global trade.


Its report, by Evenett and Johannes Fritz, a research fellow at St Gallen, found that there was no compelling case for governments to get upset about global excess capacity in manufacturing.


"On examination, it turns out that the phrase excess capacity is slippery -- rhetorically useful, but hard to pin down, even harder to operationalise, and at the same time woefully misleading."


The United States, the European Union and Japan have accused China of trading unfairly by subsidising bloated steel and aluminium sectors and flooding the world with cheap exports.


US President Donald Trump has used China's mammoth steel and aluminium sectors as justification for imposing tariffs on global supplies, causing an outcry from many countries.


Global Trade Alert has catalogued global trade policies since 2009 to gauge trends in protectionism, following a pledge by the G20 group of countries in November 2008 not to resort to trade protectionism as a response to the financial crisis.


There was no question that the steel sector was plagued by trade distortions, the study said, but G20 governments had grossly under-reported their own use of trade-distorting policies.


"Even before the recent steel tariffs were imposed by the US, the cumulative effect of the 144 American actions to limit steel imports still in effect today covered 96.8% of US steel imports," the report said.


Targeting excess steel capacity was not sensible, because measuring it was very difficult, and estimates of China's steel production capacity varied enormously, it said.


Drawing on Chinese and US sources, the study said other sectors thought to have overcapacity included glass, shipbuilding, base metals, paper, chemicals, batteries and footwear.


But for most of those, Chinese overcapacity had little impact on global trade, the study said. China's exports of those products accounted for only a small proportion of its total exports and less than 2% of G20 countries' manufacturing imports, it found.


Since 2005, no more than 21% of world trade was in sectors where China was suspected of having overcapacity, and that number had fallen from 2011 to reach 18% in 2016.


(Writing by Jessie Jia  Editing by Harry Huo)
For any questions, please contact us by inqury@fwenergy.com or +86-351-7219322.

Share this article
Connect with us

Editors Recommendations

1 China Coal Daily Track (Mar 21) 2019-03-21

Thermal coal Production area Coal prices fell by 20-30 yuan/t in Shenmu city of Shaanxi as downstream users reduced purchase owing to previous high prices. Miners in Yulin city expected further

2 Indonesian coal prices extend downtrend amid weak demand 2019-03-21

Spot prices of Indonesian thermal coal have extended the downward trend since late last week, as demand weakened after a large purchase from a state-run power producer. On March 20, the F

3 China 5,500 Kcal/kg NAR coal ceases drops as demand improves 2019-03-21

Prices of 5,500 Kcal/kg NAR coal stopped declines that had lasted for seven days at northern China ports, in response to increased buying appetite from cement plants. On March 20, the Fen

4 China Feb power consumption up 7.2% on yr, NEA 2019-03-21

China consumed 489.1 TWh of electricity in February, increasing 7.2% from the preceding year, showed data from the National Energy Administration on March 20. For the residential segment,

5 China's top 4 pig iron provinces contribute 53.6% of total output in Jan-Feb 2019-03-21

China's top four pig iron production provinces – Hebei, Jiangsu, Liaoning and Shandong – contributed 53.6% of China's total output of the material in January-February, with output combined at 67.88 mi

6 China Coal Daily Track (Mar 20) 2019-03-20

Thermal coal Production area Coal prices further dipped 10-30 yuan/t in Yulin city of Shaanxi as previous cuts failed boost sales. Traders were inactive in buying Shanxi coal amid weakening

7 China's foreign ministry reiterates environmental scrutiny on import coal 2019-03-20

China strengthened inspections of import coal to protect the interests of its companies and the environment as the country has found many overseas coal fail to meet related environmental standards dur

8 Thermal coal price spread widens at N China ports; short-term trend unclear 2019-03-20

Price spread between 5,500 Kcal/kg and 5,000 Kcal/kg NAR thermal coal further widened at northern Chinese ports, mainly resulting from a shortfall of the former. On March 19, the Fenwei C

9 CGN New Energy Feb power sales down 12.5% YoY 2019-03-20

CGN New Energy Holdings Co., Ltd., one listed company of China General Nuclear Power Corporation (CGN), sold 902.8 GWh of electricity in February, down 12.5% from the same month of a year ago, said th

10 China's rebar prices likely to go up further after breaking 4,000-yuan/t mark 2019-03-20

Prices of rebar, a major building steel material and a significant gauge to steel prices, have been edging up mildly since the middle of February. Chinese spot rebar price broke th

Most Read Articles

1 China's QHD port boosts inventories to help stabilize coal prices 2019-03-13

Qinhuangdao port, a major coal transfer hub in northern China, is expected to increase coal inflows and build up stocks, in an aim to help rein in recent coal price hikes at coastal market.

2 China coal shipping market languishes again 2019-03-12

China's coal shipping market started to lose strength following a 10-day rise, in line with increasing tepidness in coal trades at northern ports. After thermal coal prices surged to a fr

3 Indonesia, Russia coals zero in on Chinese market amid supply gap 2019-03-11

Indonesian and Russian miners zeroed in on Chinese seaborne import thermal coal market after a supply gap emerged along with China's tightened grips on Australian coal and curbed production in domesti

4 China Jan-Feb coal output falls on safety checks, NBS data 2019-03-14

China's raw coal production fall 1.5% year on year to 513.67 million tonnes in the first two months this year, data showed from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) on March 14. The ye

5 China thermal coal sales hit a roadblock 2019-03-15

Thermal coal sales were hammered in both producing regions and northern transfer ports in China, market sources confirmed with sxcoal.com, causing declines in prices of the fossil fuel.

6 Thermal coal market shows sign of slowing at Chinese N ports 2019-03-11

Traders warned there might be downward risks soon for thermal coal traded at ports in northern China when coal mines are allowed to resume production in main production areas. Triggered b

7 Indonesian thermal coal further saps as trades wind down 2019-03-15

Indonesian thermal coal prices further sapped after several days of stabilization, as the sole support of weather-interrupted shipments in Kalimantan and Sumatra has failed to offset the impact of ebb

8 Mongolia Feb coal exports up 52.63% YoY 2019-03-15

Mongolia exported 1.91 million tonnes of coal in February, increasing 52.63% year on year yet decreasing 11.63% from the previous month, showed the data from the National Statistics Office of Mongolia

9 Production resumption may allay supply concerns for thermal coal in China 2019-03-13

Chinese thermal coal miners are gradually recovering operations, boosting expectations that supply shortness will be alleviated later on. As of March 11, three batches of coal mines, 95 i

10 Weekly China coal market news summary (Mar 11 – Mar 15) 2019-03-15

China Jan-Feb coal output falls on safety checks, NBS data China's raw coal production fall 1.5% year on year to 513.67 million tonnes in the first two months this year, data showed from the Na

Scan to download sxcoal.com mobile APP

X