China speeds steel cuts as pressures rise – analysis Policy,  Environmental Protection 2018-02-27 11:11:00

China has announced plans to meet targets for downsizing its steel industry two years ahead of schedule in an apparent signal that there will be no more cuts in production capacity after 2018.


On February 7, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology (MIIT) said in a statement that China will reach targets for trimming surplus steel capacity this year instead of in 2020, Reuters reported.


In January 2016, Premier Li Keqiang first pledged to reduce overcapacity in the bloated steel sector by 100 million to 150 million tonnes without specifying a date.


In official statements and state media since then, the government's goal has been reported as 150 million tonnes by 2020.


According to MIIT statements, China has already closed at least 115 million tonnes of outmoded and excess capacity.


In 2016, the industry reportedly exceeded its goal of 45 million tonnes for the year, shutting down 65 million tonnes of capacity. Last year, it reached the annual target of 50 million tonnes by the end of August, the ministry said.


The size and pace of the cuts has been closely watched because China produces nearly half the world's crude steel with the capacity to make far more.


China's overcapacity has been a source of international tension for well over a decade, sparking complaints from foreign steelmakers over low prices, hidden subsidies and unfair export competition.


Last April, U.S. President Donald Trump ordered an investigation into whether steel imports from China and other countries pose a national security risk.


Trump is scheduled to decide on possible trade measures for steel imports by April 11, 90 days after a Commerce Department report was submitted under the rarely-used Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962. A similar decision is pending for aluminum on April 19.


Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross has recommended a choice from among three options on steel. These include a 24% tariff on imports from all countries, a 53% tariff on steel from China and 11 other countries, combined with quota restrictions on other exporters, or quotas on imports from all countries.


On February 17, China's Ministry of Commerce (MOC) called the U.S. finding of a national security threat "groundless" and warned of retaliation.


"If the United States' final decision affects China's interests, we will take necessary measures to defend our rights," said Wang Hejun, head of the MOC trade remedy and investigation bureau, as quoted by the official Xinhua news agency.


But China also has reasons of its own for tightening up on steel, which has been a major source of coal consumption and smog.


Last March, central government and municipal authorities unveiled plans to restrict steel production in northern areas surrounding Beijing during the winter heating season starting November 15, reducing output by half at most mills.


The limits appear to have helped Beijing to avoid a repeat of last winter's smog crisis, but the controls will be lifted on March 15, opening the door to a surge in production again.


On February 26, Reuters reported that Tangshan city in Hebei province is considering a draft plan to extend the restrictions for some capacity until November to help reduce smog.


It is unclear whether the extension will take place or whether other steelmakers would boost production in response.


But even with the winter cutbacks, China's crude steel production rose 5.7% last year to a record 831.7 million tonnes, according to the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS).


China's capacity cutting has only a tangential effect on production, primarily because its overcapacity has been so huge.


For years, state media reports have highlighted China's capacity cuts without quantifying the total size of the industry's production capacity.


But in April 2016, a senior MIIT official said China's capacity stood at 1.13 billion tonnes, Reuters reported at the time. The total leaves 326 million tonnes as surplus, based on NBS production figures for 2015.


As a result, China's targeted cuts of 150 million tonnes would eliminate only 46% of its excess, allowing steelmakers to set records for output despite the capacity reductions.


The extent of the downsizing makes it critical to know whether China's announcement on achieving the target means it has no plans to do more.


So far, China is celebrating the results of its policies, since the cuts have had a psychological effect on the market, returning the industry to profitability.


"Steel prices soared on expectations that supply would tighten due to capacity cuts," the official English-language China Daily reported, citing a jump of more than 50% for benchmark rebar last year.


But the policies have done little to address foreign complaints about China's production volumes and market dominance.


Last year, China's global market share for crude steel rose to 49.2% from 49% in 2016, the World Steel Association said.


Since 2016, the capacity cuts have actually encouraged more production as some steelmakers reopened closed lines to take advantage of higher prices.


In recent weeks, MIIT has issued tough statements on keeping capacity in check without ruling out possible production increases.

On January 8, the ministry said it would require steelmakers to eliminate 1.25 tonnes of old capacity for every new ton of modern capacity they add this year.


"We will strictly forbid any new steel capacity to be launched and make sure all outdated steel capacity is eliminated and prevented from reopening," the ministry pledged in an earlier statement.


But the country's biggest producer, state-owned China Baowu Steel Group, has already announced plans to expand in the longer term as smaller private competitors are pressured to shut down, the South China Morning Post reported in September.


Baowu Steel has targeted an increase in capacity from 60 million tonnes to 100 million tonnes, the company's general manager said.


Derek Scissors, an Asia economist and resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington, said the impact of China’s cuts depends on what it plans to do next.


"The Chinese steel sector was 35% to 40% oversized," Scissors said. "Now it may be only half that. The bloat was so bad that capacity cuts have had no visible effect on production, but they still needed to be made.”


"If Beijing now declares victory and the industry goes back to business as usual, the whole program was a farce," he said.


"If they make no further capacity cuts but prevent re-expansion, the true target was only consolidation of larger state-owned enterprises, as the central government has long wanted," said Scissors.


"But there's at least more of a chance to actually shrink steel now than there was in 2014," he concluded.


While much may depend on the psychological effects of the numbers, there are several reasons to doubt the numbers themselves.


Last year, a study sponsored by Greenpeace East Asia found that 54 million tonnes of operations that were claimed as capacity cuts in 2016 had restarted due to price increases.


It is unclear whether the government has continued to count such temporary closures in its totals of shutdowns.


Another analysis by the Peterson Institute for International Economics argued that 200 million tonnes of spare capacity was reasonable for China's steel industry to respond to market fluctuations. But it also said that officials had mixed iron and steel together in their reports, making it unclear whether the goals for crude steel have been met.


China has also claimed gains in ending 140 million tonnes of illicit production of substandard steel made with induction furnaces using scrap metal. The products are not included in the steel capacity cut totals, although they affect prices and smog-producing emissions.


Whether the production has been permanently eliminated may be open to question.


"Induction furnaces have been a thorn in the eye of Chinese steel industrial policy since 2002, but have largely been successful in evading measures," the report said.


"The more underground, home-brew operations play a cat-and-mouse game with the authorities. They simply dismantle facilities quickly before inspections, and assemble them again after," it said, quoting "market participants."


(Writing by William Gao  Editing by Jessie Jia)
For any questions, please contact us by or +86-351-7219322.

Share this article
Connect with us

Editors Recommendations

1 Shanxi's 1st new coal mine project starts construction 2018-09-19

China's coal-rich Shanxi province recently started building a new coal mine project, which is the first of such project in 13 years, said sources from the Shanxi Provincial Department of Land and Reso

2 China Aug coal output rises despite environmental and safety checks 2018-09-19

China's raw coal output increased in August compared to the year-ago and month-ago levels, in spite of environmental and safety checks that impacted production in some production areas. T

3 China Coal Daily Track (Sep 19) 2018-09-19

Thermal coal Domestic market A few miners cut down thermal coal prices by 10-20 yuan/t in Yuyang district of Yulin city, Shaanxi province, in response to reduced purchase from Shanxi

4 Vietnam Aug coal imports up 7% on yr 2018-09-19

Southeastern Asian country Vietnam imported 1.52 million tonnes of coal in August, dropping 10.4% on the month but rising 7.14% from the year prior, showed data from Vietnamese customs. V

5 Indonesian coal prices advances after N China's port restricted shipment 2018-09-19

Indonesian miners raised their thermal coal offer prices after China's largest coal-dedicated port limited coal shipment, sources said. One Singapore-based trader reported Indonesian pric

6 China spot thermal coal market in wait-and-see 2018-09-19

Spot thermal coal trades were locked in a standoff at northern China ports, as wait-and-see sentiment has started to increase at seller and buyer sides. "Most suppliers are just taking a

7 Taiwan Aug coal imports down 4% YoY 2018-09-19

Taiwan imported 6.07 million tonnes of coal in August, down 3.66% year on year and 10.56% from July, preliminary customs data showed. In August, Taiwan imported 5.25 millio

8 Australian miner New Hope says coal prices to push higher 2018-09-18

Australian miner New Hope Corp on September 18 said thermal coal prices would push higher in coming months, extending a rise that helped boost its profits in the last financial year. The

9 Dozens of miners raised coal prices by 5-15 yuan/t in Shaanxi's Yulin 2018-09-18

Dozens of miners were synchronously raising coal prices in Yulin city since September 16, northwestern China's Shaanxi province, backed by robust pre-winter restocking in Northeastern China.

10 China Aug power coal price index slides after two-month rebound 2018-09-18

China's monthly-issued price index of power coal edged down 1.9% month on month to 522.4 yuan/t in August, following pickups in June and July, showed data from the National Development and Reform Comm

Most Read Articles

1 High cost props up coal prices at N Chinese ports 2018-09-11

Chinese thermal coal market gained strength at the beginning of this week from stiff prices at production areas, which, plus transport fees, pushed coal prices up at northern ports. The m

2 More Mongolian coking coals flow into China, helping ease supply tightness 2018-09-12

Tightness of coking coal supply in China, caused mainly by strengthened environment-related production restrictions, is expected to get eased moderately with increased arrivals of Mongolian coal follo

3 China import thermal coal prices steadily rise to track domestic upturn 2018-09-10

Prices of import thermal coal offered to Chinese buyers continued to inch up late last week, aligning with recent upturns in China's domestic market. The uptick seen in Indonesian coal wa

4 China import thermal coal market still lacks upbeat momentum 2018-09-11

Not many deals were concluded for import thermal coal at the beginning of this week, said market sources in China, on a lack of support from the demand side. "Recent import market just sh

5 China mulls flexible output curbs in heavy industries this winter, sources 2018-09-13

China is considering allowing its northern provinces to decide individual output cuts by heavy industries including steel to rein in emissions during the winter, sources said. This

6 Chinese thermal coal stays range-bound; demand bounces back 2018-09-10

Chinese spot thermal coal market has moved in a narrowed range for nearly two weeks, with both sellers and buyers keeping the price wrestling but failing to tip the balance. By September

7 Rising demand paints a rosy picture for China's thermal coal market 2018-09-11

Coal miners in main-producing areas of China are optimistic about thermal coal market in the future, as demand continues to increase. Currently, lump coal prices kept climbing up in Ordos

8 China's Aug coal imports rise 13.49% on yr 2018-09-10

China's coal imports climbed by 13.49% from a year earlier to 28.68 million tonnes in August, showed data from the General Administration of Customs (GAC) on September 8. The impo

9 China Aug coal exports skyrocket 710% on yr 2018-09-10

China's coal exports reached 486,000 tonnes in August, surging 710% on the year and 14.35% on the month, showed data released by the General Administration of Customs on September 8.

10 China's coal imports likely to hit 4-yr high at around 300 Mt in 2018 2018-09-12

China's coal import volume is very likely to reach a four-year high of 300 million tonnes or so this year, market observers have anticipated. The latest customs data that showed China imp